Performance Comparison of Routing Protocols for Mobile and Stationary WSNs

Authors

  • Ramadhan A. Rai The State University of Zanzibar
  • Ali I. Adnan The State University of Zanzibar
  • Omar H. Kombo The State University of Zanzibar

Abstract

Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) serve as vital elements in the landscape of Internet of Things (IoT) applications, environmental monitoring, and emergency response systems. Efficient routing protocols are critical for reliable data delivery and energy conservation in WSNs. This research examines routing protocols, specifically the ad-hoc On-Demand Distance Vector (AODV) and the Destination-Sequenced Distance Vector (DSDV) in both Stationary WSNs (SWSNs) and Mobile WSNs (MWSNs). Using the NS-2 simulator, we analysed the network performance under varying node densities (20–60 nodes) and calculated the link budget to ensure connectivity. The metrics encompass throughput, packet delivery ratio, E2E delay, and energy consumption. Statistical analysis using t-tests was used to evaluate the performance differences under random node placement and mobility patterns. The results indicate that AODV outperforms DSDV in SWSNs, whereas both protocols perform comparably in MWSNs. These findings provide guidance for selecting routing protocols based on network mobility and application requirements.

☍ View Article Analytics

Author Biographies

Ramadhan A. Rai, The State University of Zanzibar

Department of Computer Science and Information Technology

Ali I. Adnan, The State University of Zanzibar

Department of Computer Science and Information Technology

Omar H. Kombo, The State University of Zanzibar

Department of Computer Science and Information Technology

Downloads

Published

2026-06-30

Issue

Section

Articles